Handle This!?!

[Aaron]

I was wondering how Handle This got onto ATGS. It's all that great of a song. What songs do you guys think should have made it that didn't and not should have made it that did.

Doesn't Deserve it:Handle This
Deserved it but didn't make it:Pull The Curtain, King Of Contradiction

[Nic]

In my opinion Handle This deserved every bit to be both greatest hits records. It's a great song. What I want to know is why Always didn't make ATGS but it made 8 Years Of...

[I'm A Cunt [*banned*]]

Because it was one of their singles?

[Jeremy Kill]

I think all the songs currently on All the Good Shit deserve to be on there. They should've added a few more songs make it a 20 track disc though.

Songs That Should've Made It:
No Reason
The Bitter End (Heaviest Sum 41 song, so that's an achievement in its own right)
88
Dave's Possessed Hair
Second Chance for Max Headroom

If anything, the disc needed more Half Hour of Power.

[CIRCUITzach]

hell song live.
why not put on ANIC instead lol jk
id like to see like No Reason, i like this song a lot i think its one of their best.
question
when they retire and have new greatest hit, will these songs be on there, i know they will though
why not just wait till they retire and put out like a 2 cd greatest hits

[Jeremy Kill]

hell song live.
why not put on ANIC instead lol jk
id like to see like No Reason, i like this song a lot i think its one of their best.
question
when they retire and have new greatest hit, will these songs be on there, i know they will though
why not just wait till they retire and put out like a 2 cd greatest hits

I'm thinking it'll be like Blink-182's greatest hits where they had all the band's singles in chronological order.

[CIRCUITzach]

oh so same songs different order plus the future hits?

[Jeremy Kill]

oh so same songs different order plus the future hits?

Yeah and probably a couple cover/b-side/unreleased tracks.

I hope they throw in something extra though, like if they keep doing Road to Ruins and have some unreleased episodes or something, that would be nice.

[Dylan]

they should've waited until 2010 and have a decade selection. possibly a 2 disc set. i'd have the singles

Makes no Difference
Fat Lip
In Too Deep
Handle This Motivation
What We're All About
Pain For Pleasure
Hell Song
Still Waiting
Over My Head
We're All to Blame
Some Say
Pieces
No Reason (radio single)
Underclass Hero
Walking Disaster
With Me

and other GREAT songs:
Machine Gun
Summer
Mr. Amsterdam
No Brains
88
There's No Solution
Pull The Curtain

plus Always and possible another new song. now THAT would be a "All The Good Shit" collection.

[Jeremy Kill]

Yeah, this one should actually be named "This is Just Some of the Good Shit" or something.

[CIRCUITzach]

i like their morning glory cover

[sumfan4]

Yeah, this one should actually be named "This is Just Some of the Good Shit" or something.

I think handle this deserves it. its a good song, and it was a single. I think ATGS is gonna be great

[Kelbunk]

for the next one they should put the singles, and hold some sort of vote on their website to see which other songs make it

[Phili]

It's a greatest hits album. Therefore, all of their singles are on the album and really nothing else. It's really quite simple.

[Dylan]

^ yes, but they decided to call "ALL the good shit" i would have to disagree with that title. it does not have nearly all the good "shit" on it. there are plenty of band who have "greats hits" packages that aren't solely singles.

[rockindrummer41]

I think all the songs currently on All the Good Shit deserve to be on there. They should've added a few more songs make it a 20 track disc though.

Songs That Should've Made It:
No Reason
The Bitter End (Heaviest Sum 41 song, so that's an achievement in its own right)
88
Dave's Possessed Hair
Second Chance for Max Headroom

If anything, the disc needed more Half Hour of Power.

and Pull the Curtain
Angels with Dirty Faces

[Phili]

^ yes, but they decided to call "ALL the good shit" i would have to disagree with that title. it does not have nearly all the good "shit" on it. there are plenty of band who have "greats hits" packages that aren't solely singles.

...The other stuff is always bonus tracks.

[upperclasszero]

handle this deserves it

[iemnaiz]

i'm disappointed that No Reason isn't on it. it's their best song!

[Emil]

I don't get irt why What We're All About did'nt make it on there. It was an official single and it had a music video and everything.