Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Moderator: Jeremy Kill
- Ferdehh41
- Ma Poubelle
- Posts: 666
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2011 5:26 pm
- First name: Ferdi
- Age: 23
- Gender: ♂
- PSN ID: ferdehh182
- Location: Holland
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
agreedespinozac182 wrote:i can't wait to hear the live version of "Blood In My Eyes".
- SumGeek
- Does This Look Infected?
- Posts: 1858
- Joined: Thu Apr 08, 2010 7:19 pm
- First name: Chelsea
- Age: 23
- Gender: ♀
- Twitter: chelsealouanne
- Location: Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
- Contact:
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
So do I, those are two of my favourites but not replacing Fat Lip and In Too Deep in the set.Emil wrote:I want No Brains and Machine Gun back.
- gejmik
- Chuck
- Posts: 2090
- Joined: Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:12 pm
- First name: Tomas
- Age: 26
- Gender: ♂
- PSN ID: GameEsCZ
- Instrument 1: guitar
- Last.fm Username: GameEs
- Twitter: gamees41
- Location: Czech Republic
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
I'd raise the set with them.SumGeek wrote:So do I, those are two of my favourites but not replacing Fat Lip and In Too Deep in the set.Emil wrote:I want No Brains and Machine Gun back.
- Gutter Dreams
- Moderator
- Posts: 3141
- Joined: Tue Sep 01, 2009 1:48 pm
- First name: Sarah
- Age: 19
- Gender: ♀
- PSN ID: SarahFTL
- Instrument 1: Guitar
- Twitter: sarrrwhite
- Location: Canada(!)
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
I don't think they will ever take Fat Lip outSumGeek wrote:So do I, those are two of my favourites but not replacing Fat Lip and In Too Deep in the set.Emil wrote:I want No Brains and Machine Gun back.
-
- Chuck
- Posts: 2224
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2011 11:02 pm
- First name: Al
- Age: 17
- Gender: ♀
- n00b: Myself
- Instrument 1: Guitar
- Instrument 2: Drums and Harmonica
- Instrument 3: Bass and Piano
- Location: USA
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
They need to play Some Say more
- Gutter Dreams
- Moderator
- Posts: 3141
- Joined: Tue Sep 01, 2009 1:48 pm
- First name: Sarah
- Age: 19
- Gender: ♀
- PSN ID: SarahFTL
- Instrument 1: Guitar
- Twitter: sarrrwhite
- Location: Canada(!)
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
not gonna lie, had totally forgotten about that one! I like this though, it'd be cool if they put it back in. even if it wasn't in every setlist, just a couple and I'd be satisfied for that.SickofEveryone wrote:They need to play Some Say more
- ÜBERCUNT
- Does This Look Infected?
- Posts: 1715
- Joined: Sat Mar 12, 2011 4:16 pm
- First name: Sigfried
- Age: 12
- Gender: ♂
- n00b: Me
- AKA: NEEERD
- Instrument 1: Guitar hero
- Last.fm Username: daddyissues
- Twitter: @Piersmorgan
- Location: The library
- Contact:
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Some say was AMAZINGG live!!! but idk it'll work like it did back in 2005,SickofEveryone wrote:They need to play Some Say more
they're not the same band anymore...they write better songs now- but live is ehh....better than rise against live, but they're no green day when it comes to live performances
- SBMurder
- Ma Poubelle
- Posts: 626
- Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2011 5:59 am
- First name: Jeff
- Age: 18
- Gender: ♂
- Location: Whitby,Ontario,Canada
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Maybe Deryck will surprise us with his voice on the SBM Tour who knowscladam41 wrote:Some say was AMAZINGG live!!! but idk it'll work like it did back in 2005,SickofEveryone wrote:They need to play Some Say more
they're not the same band anymore...they write better songs now- but live is ehh....better than rise against live, but they're no green day when it comes to live performances
- ÜBERCUNT
- Does This Look Infected?
- Posts: 1715
- Joined: Sat Mar 12, 2011 4:16 pm
- First name: Sigfried
- Age: 12
- Gender: ♂
- n00b: Me
- AKA: NEEERD
- Instrument 1: Guitar hero
- Last.fm Username: daddyissues
- Twitter: @Piersmorgan
- Location: The library
- Contact:
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
from what I've heard so far- I'm not too convincedSBMurder wrote:Maybe Deryck will surprise us with his voice on the SBM Tour who knowscladam41 wrote:Some say was AMAZINGG live!!! but idk it'll work like it did back in 2005,SickofEveryone wrote:They need to play Some Say more
they're not the same band anymore...they write better songs now- but live is ehh....better than rise against live, but they're no green day when it comes to live performances
- SBMurder
- Ma Poubelle
- Posts: 626
- Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2011 5:59 am
- First name: Jeff
- Age: 18
- Gender: ♂
- Location: Whitby,Ontario,Canada
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
He might be saving his voice for when he plays the other songs on the album or he might just not have the voice for these songscladam41 wrote:from what I've heard so far- I'm not too convincedSBMurder wrote:Maybe Deryck will surprise us with his voice on the SBM Tour who knowscladam41 wrote:Some say was AMAZINGG live!!! but idk it'll work like it did back in 2005,SickofEveryone wrote:They need to play Some Say more
they're not the same band anymore...they write better songs now- but live is ehh....better than rise against live, but they're no green day when it comes to live performances
- TomiT14
- Moderator
- Posts: 4261
- Joined: Fri Apr 13, 2007 2:19 pm
- First name: Tomi
- Age: 31
- Gender: ♂
- PSN ID: TJT41
- Last.fm Username: TomiT14
- Twitter: TomiT14
- Location: Espoo, Finland
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Luckily so. Relatively Sums are way better. If the Sums brought the explosions and other theatricals along with the extended setlist, they would be the same at its worst.cladam41 wrote:but they're no green day when it comes to live performances
But I don't want the Sums to become like Green Day. I love how Sum 41 is an awesome live band without any special effects.
- greenday1987
- Newbie
- Posts: 27
- Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2011 1:05 pm
- First name: Jonathan
- Age: 23
- Gender: ♂
- Location: Bourges, France
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Sum 41 live is better than Green Day? Sum 41 play approximatively 1h and play the same songs over and over. Deryck are unable to sing some songs and the band is worst than ever onstage.TomiT14 wrote:Luckily so. Relatively Sums are way better. If the Sums brought the explosions and other theatricals along with the extended setlist, they would be the same at its worst.cladam41 wrote:but they're no green day when it comes to live performances
But I don't want the Sums to become like Green Day. I love how Sum 41 is an awesome live band without any special effects.
"No man can eat 50 eggs."
- gejmik
- Chuck
- Posts: 2090
- Joined: Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:12 pm
- First name: Tomas
- Age: 26
- Gender: ♂
- PSN ID: GameEsCZ
- Instrument 1: guitar
- Last.fm Username: GameEs
- Twitter: gamees41
- Location: Czech Republic
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Wow, you're green day fan, aren't you.greenday1987 wrote:Sum 41 live is better than Green Day? Sum 41 play approximatively 1h and play the same songs over and over. Deryck are unable to sing some songs and the band is worst than ever onstage.TomiT14 wrote:Luckily so. Relatively Sums are way better. If the Sums brought the explosions and other theatricals along with the extended setlist, they would be the same at its worst.cladam41 wrote:but they're no green day when it comes to live performances
But I don't want the Sums to become like Green Day. I love how Sum 41 is an awesome live band without any special effects.
But yeah, Green Day show was the most amazing one I've been on.
Along with all the Sum 41 shows.
- TomiT14
- Moderator
- Posts: 4261
- Joined: Fri Apr 13, 2007 2:19 pm
- First name: Tomi
- Age: 31
- Gender: ♂
- PSN ID: TJT41
- Last.fm Username: TomiT14
- Twitter: TomiT14
- Location: Espoo, Finland
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Did you even read my post?greenday1987 wrote:Sum 41 live is better than Green Day? Sum 41 play approximatively 1h and play the same songs over and over. Deryck are unable to sing some songs and the band is worst than ever onstage.TomiT14 wrote:Luckily so. Relatively Sums are way better. If the Sums brought the explosions and other theatricals along with the extended setlist, they would be the same at its worst.cladam41 wrote:but they're no green day when it comes to live performances
But I don't want the Sums to become like Green Day. I love how Sum 41 is an awesome live band without any special effects.
If Green Day played only one hour set, they would have quite similar setlist from show to show. But since they play 2h30min sets, there's room to play not-so-famous songs that can be switched.TomiT14 wrote:If the Sums brought the explosions and other theatricals along with the extended setlist, they would be the same at its worst.
Also, your arguement is invalid, I'm not sure why I even talk to you about this. Have you even been to a Sum 41 show in the past year? Deryck's voice has improved drastically (Rebel Yell, anyone?), and the onstage performance is very amusing. No more over-rehearsed stage banter, and the band plays with the crowd more than ever.
Green Day, I don't say they are bad. In fact, they are probably the best live band today. But relatively, Sums are better in my opinion. I've been to two GD concerts, almost one year apart (although both were during 21CB era), and those two shows were not only exactly the same, but were also VERY similar to Bullet In The Bible live DVD. All three of them had same crowd plays, while the two shows I went to had the exact same setlist, excluding only one (1) song.
The length or the variety of a setlist is not the only meter to determine a good live band. I saw the Sums twice in two days in Prague. The setlists were almost identical, but still the shows themselves were totally different from eachother. The atmosphere, crowd plays and stage banter were completely different.
But yeah, no need to get heated just because I critisized (note: not 'bashed') your favorite band. I was just giving an opinion with a valid point reflecting from my experience.
Then again, why am I telling you this? You don't even seem to understand anything about live shows.
- greenday1987
- Newbie
- Posts: 27
- Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2011 1:05 pm
- First name: Jonathan
- Age: 23
- Gender: ♂
- Location: Bourges, France
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
In my opinion, Deryck has no charisma or talent of Billie Joe. Green Day is able to transcend his songs on stage, give them another dimension. Sum 41 is not capable.
"No man can eat 50 eggs."
- TomiT14
- Moderator
- Posts: 4261
- Joined: Fri Apr 13, 2007 2:19 pm
- First name: Tomi
- Age: 31
- Gender: ♂
- PSN ID: TJT41
- Last.fm Username: TomiT14
- Twitter: TomiT14
- Location: Espoo, Finland
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Well, that's your opinion. I can't understand how you don't see the talent of Deryck's and Sum 41's. They are generally known to be one of the best live bands today, especially in smaller venues.greenday1987 wrote:In my opinion, Deryck has no charisma or talent of Billie Joe. Green Day is able to transcend his songs on stage, give them another dimension. Sum 41 is not capable.
And Deryck doesn't have charisma or talent of Billie Joe's? Of course not! They are two totally different persons!
I'm not telling you to like Sum 41, but you should open your eyes and see that they really are a great live band. Maybe not better than Green Day, but nowhere near bad either.
- sumelf
- Hooch
- Posts: 427
- Joined: Wed Apr 30, 2008 8:09 pm
- Age: 25
- Gender: ♂
- Instrument 1: Drums
- Instrument 2: Guitar
- Location: Russia, Moscow
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Green Day sucks live for only one reason. They've never (or for a long time) played in my country. Sums're going for the third time. So fuck GD.
- greenday1987
- Newbie
- Posts: 27
- Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2011 1:05 pm
- First name: Jonathan
- Age: 23
- Gender: ♂
- Location: Bourges, France
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
I never said that Sum 41 was bad, just that Green Day was better on stage.
I like Sum 41 but I wish they would play longer and their are more varied setlist.
I think they was better live during DTLI and Chuck era.
I like Sum 41 but I wish they would play longer and their are more varied setlist.
I think they was better live during DTLI and Chuck era.
Last edited by greenday1987 on Wed Apr 27, 2011 2:52 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"No man can eat 50 eggs."
- TomiT14
- Moderator
- Posts: 4261
- Joined: Fri Apr 13, 2007 2:19 pm
- First name: Tomi
- Age: 31
- Gender: ♂
- PSN ID: TJT41
- Last.fm Username: TomiT14
- Twitter: TomiT14
- Location: Espoo, Finland
Re: Deryck's Top 10 songs to play live
Really?greenday1987 wrote:I never said that Sum 41 was bad.
greenday1987 wrote:Sum 41 play the same songs over and over. Deryck are unable to sing some songs and the band is worst than ever onstage.
greenday1987 wrote:Deryck has no charisma or talent of Billie Joe. Sum 41 is not capable.