Page 1 of 6

The Official Non-Official Album Review Thread

Posted: Wed May 23, 2007 3:28 am
by duck
Ok, the point of this thread is simple. Feeling creative? Want to write about how good your favorite album is? Or how bad that new album from that band that used to be cool was? Write a review here. You can go song by song or just write something about the album in general. I'll post a few when I have time.

Include:

Band Name
Album Name
Band Members
Best Songs
Worst Songs
Rating out of 5

Posted: Wed May 23, 2007 3:48 am
by duck
Image
(+44)
When Your Heart Stops Beating
2006 Interscope

Mark Hoppus - Bass, Vocals
Craig Fairbaugh - Guitar, Backing Vocals
Shane Gallagher - Guitar
Travis Barker - Drums

When I first picked up this album last November, the best way to describe my feelings was that I was shaking in excitement. It had been, after all, three years since the other two members of blink-182 released some new material. I read in interviews that it wasn't going to be "electronically tinged" like originally promised, and I was mildly dissapointed, but still very excited to take a listen.

So what did I think of the album? It was mostly good. It was fantastic to hear Mark's voice again, and he'd obviosuly taken it to the next level with this album. He simply sounds fantastic on this CD. The lyrics are his best yet, as well as his melodies. The bass is perfect. Travis Barker's drumming is excellent, even if it doesn't quite reach the level that he did in 2001's Take Off Your Pants And Jacket. Carol's vocals in Weatherman and Make You Smile were a wonderful touch, and Baby Come On was obviosuly one of the best songs of the year.

However, the album had one serious pitfall: the guitar work. Like... damn. The guitars in songs such as 155 are so brutally uncreative I wanted to stab myself in the ears. Even the guitar parts that seem ildly creative are actually quite complex. It was very dissapointed. I don't know if it was Hoppus who wrote these guitar parts before he had some real guitarists on board or what but it simply needs some work.

In short, Mark Hoppus' vocal and lyrical mastery saved thsi album from being a mess. For example, his fantastic melody on 155 simply salvaged that song and actually made it good.

3.5/5

Best Song: BABY COME ON
Worst Song: CLIFF DIVING



ps I'm going to rate blink-182 (untitled), BT2 and Black Parade tommorow! Everyone should get invovled and post some album reviews for stuff that we've never heard before, widen our musical boundaries, ya? Ya. Plus it's fun to write.

Posted: Wed May 23, 2007 4:13 am
by Painkiller!
good idea dude ;)


front cover (700Kb)
http://www.44disasters.com/carvupload/l ... page_1.jpg

The Used
Lies For The Liars
2007 Reprise Records

Band Members:
Bert McCracken (Vocals)
Jeph Howard (Bass)
Quinn Allman (Guitar)
Dan Whitesides (Drums)

Best Songs:
The Ripper
Liar Liar (Burn In Hell)
The Bird And The Worm
Hospital
... i love every song 8)

Worst Songs:
nahhh...

5/5


i've been listening this band for 3 years, they are awesome
their first albums are really good too
:D

Posted: Wed May 23, 2007 5:04 am
by duck
That's interesting, I read a review from another guy who loved this band until this album. I heard the first three songs are amazing though, maybe ill check those out.

Posted: Wed May 23, 2007 8:04 am
by Jon Nolan
Maybe i'll do one later

Posted: Wed May 23, 2007 9:46 pm
by Jessica
Image

Brand New
Deja Entendu
2003 Triple Crown Records

Jesse Lacey- Vocals/Guitar
Vincent Accardi- Lead Guitar/Backing Vocals
Garrett Tierney- Bass
Brian Lane- Drums

ok, so this is seriously one of the best albums ive ever listened to. i know its one of those albums i can pop in anytime, and immediately relate to the music, and never get tired of. From the first track, Tautou, to Play Crack the Sky, its all simply amazing. Jesse Lacey's vocals, are so soothing and incredible at the same time. It has some of the best lyrics i've ever heard. Overal, it's such an amazing album.

Best Songs:
Sic Transit Gloria...Glory Fades
Okay I Believe You, But My Tommy Gun Don't
The Quiet Things That No One Ever Knows
Guernica
Play Crack The Sky

Worst Songs:
none

My Rating:
5/5


i highly recommend this album, even if you never heard of brand new. just check out the album, and im sure you'll love it, like I did.

Posted: Fri May 25, 2007 3:13 am
by Painkiller!
Image

AFI
Decemberunderground
2006 Interscope

Band Members:
Davey Havok (Vocals)
Jade Puget (Guitar, Backing Vocals)
Hunter Burgan (Bass, Backing Vocals)
Adam Carson (Drums)

Best Songs:
Love Like Winter
Summer Shudder
The Killing Lights
37mm
... every song

Worst Songs:
-

5/5

this is one of my favorite albums ever, i've listened it so many times
highly recommend, this band is one of the biggest punk rock bands right now... for me 8)
if you've never heard of them... http://www.myspace.com/afi
;)

Posted: Tue May 29, 2007 9:42 pm
by Boni
Image

Band Name
Bullet For My Valentine

Album Name
The Poison
Columbia (UK) [October 3, 2005]
Trustkill Records (U.S.) [February 14, 2006]

Band Members
Matthew Tuck - Vocals & Guitar
Michael Paget - Guitar
Jason James - Bass
Michael Thomas - Drum Kit

Best Song
Spit You Out

Worst Song
The End

Rating out of 5
5/5

I love this album, This is one of my favourite bands

Posted: Wed May 30, 2007 9:05 am
by Jon Nolan
Image
Band Name
Green Day
Album Name
Dookie
Band Members
Billie Joe Armstrong - Lead Vocals/Guitar
Mike Dirnt - Bass/Backing Vocals
Tre Cool - Drums
Best Songs
Welcome to Paradise
Worst Songs
In The End
Rating out of 5
4/5

Go listen to it, its rad 8)

Posted: Wed May 30, 2007 10:57 am
by call me brett
this is a really good idea.
Image
Band Name
Billy Talent
Album Name
Billy Talent II (original aye?)
Band Members
Ian D'sa - Guitar, Vocals
Jon Gallant - Bass, Vocals
Ben Kowalewicz - Main Vocals
Aaron - Drums
Best Songs
Perfect World
Fallen Leaves
This Suffering
Red Flag
and of course Devil in a midnight mass
Worst Songs
Burn The evidence
Rating
4.5/5

This has got to be one of my favourite albums EVER!

Posted: Wed May 30, 2007 9:51 pm
by Jessica
Jon wrote:Image
Band Name
Green Day
Album Name
Dookie
Band Members
Billie Joe Armstrong - Lead Vocals/Guitar
Mike Dirnt - Bass/Backing Vocals
Tre Cool - Drums
Best Songs
Welcome to Paradise
Worst Songs
In The End
Rating out of 5
4/5

Go listen to it, its rad 8)
that album so deserves a 6/5. its that awesome
i think the best songs are:
Longview and Basket Case

and i dont have a worst song 8)

Posted: Wed May 30, 2007 10:05 pm
by Nic
This is a great idea duck. I'm stickying it. 8)

Posted: Wed May 30, 2007 10:17 pm
by Macbeth!
Image
2005
Fueled by Ramen

Band Name
Paramore
Album Name
All we Know is Falling
band members
Performance Credits

Jason Bynum - Guitar, Vocals, Group Member
Josh Farro -Guitar, Vocals, Group Member
Zac Farro - Drums, Group Member
John Hembree - Bass, Group Member
Lucio Rubino - Bass
Hayley Williams -Vocals, Group Member
Jeremy Davis - Bass

Best Songs
all of them
Rating out of 5
5/5

Posted: Thu May 31, 2007 6:02 am
by call me brett
jay wrote:Image
2005
Fueled by Ramen

Band Name
Paramore
Album Name
All we Know is Falling
band members
Performance Credits

Jason Bynum - Guitar, Vocals, Group Member
Josh Farro -Guitar, Vocals, Group Member
Zac Farro - Drums, Group Member
John Hembree - Bass, Group Member
Lucio Rubino - Bass
Hayley Williams -Vocals, Group Member
Jeremy Davis - Bass

Best Songs
all of them
Rating out of 5
5/5
theres 7 people in that band?

Posted: Thu May 31, 2007 6:09 am
by Macbeth!
call me brett wrote: theres 7 people in that band?
no it's called Performance Credits the four band members are
Zac and Josh Farro, and Hayley

Posted: Thu May 31, 2007 8:12 pm
by Macbeth!
Image
2005
Virgin Records

Band Name
30 Seconds to mars

album
A Beautiful Lie

band members
Jared Leto- vocals, rhythm guitar
Tomo Miličević - lead guitar
Matt Wachter - bass
Shannon Leto - drums, guitar, vocals

Best songs
attack
A Beautiful Lie
The Kill
From Yesterday

worst song
Hunter

This album was different then their self titled album musically and lyrically.
this is album you should check out.

4/5

Posted: Fri Jun 15, 2007 1:11 pm
by budgie
Image

Band Name
Muse
Album Name
Absolution

2003

Band Members
Matthew Bellamy - guitar, piano, synthesizers, vocals
Chris Wolstenholme - bass, synthesizers, backing vocals
Dom Howard - drums, percussion

Best Songs
Apocalypse Please
Time is Running Out
Sing For Absolution
Stockholm Syndrome (NOT the same as the blink song)
Falling Away With You
Hysteria
The Small Print
Thoughts of a Dying Atheist

Worst Songs
Intro

Rating out of 5
5

a great album; a little mental, but an instant classic.
full of powerful and emotional songs about the end of the world (cheery stuff, isnt it? :lol:)

Posted: Wed Jul 25, 2007 2:14 pm
by Bobbyjames
Jessica wrote:Image

Brand New
Deja Entendu
2003 Triple Crown Records

Jesse Lacey- Vocals/Guitar
Vincent Accardi- Lead Guitar/Backing Vocals
Garrett Tierney- Bass
Brian Lane- Drums

ok, so this is seriously one of the best albums ive ever listened to. i know its one of those albums i can pop in anytime, and immediately relate to the music, and never get tired of. From the first track, Tautou, to Play Crack the Sky, its all simply amazing. Jesse Lacey's vocals, are so soothing and incredible at the same time. It has some of the best lyrics i've ever heard. Overal, it's such an amazing album.

Best Songs:
Sic Transit Gloria...Glory Fades
Okay I Believe You, But My Tommy Gun Don't
The Quiet Things That No One Ever Knows
Guernica
Play Crack The Sky

Worst Songs:
none

My Rating:
5/5


i highly recommend this album, even if you never heard of brand new. just check out the album, and im sure you'll love it, like I did.
one of my favourite albums of all time, i love it, every song is amazing!

Posted: Wed Jul 25, 2007 4:19 pm
by budgie
Image

Band Name
Foo Fighters
Album Name
The Colour & The Shape

1997

Band Members
Dave Grohl - guitars, drums, vocals
Pat Smear - guitars, backing vocals
Nate Mendel - bass, backing vocals

Best Songs
Monkey Wrench
Hey, Johnny Park!
Wind Up
Up in Arms
My Hero
February Stars
Everlong
New Way Home

Worst Songs
Doll

Rating out of 5
4.5

another one of my favourite albums. its got basically everything we all love about the foo fighters... even rock music in general. this is about as good as it gets.
i recommend you check it out if you havent already.

Posted: Wed Jul 25, 2007 8:23 pm
by Lithium
Image

Band name
Blink 182
Album Name
Blink-182
Released
November 18, 2003
Producer
Jerry Finn
Label
Geffen Records

Band Members
Mark Hoppus-Bass,vocals
Tom Delonge-Guitars,vocals
Travis Barker-Drums

Best Songs
Feeling This
I Miss You
Down
Easy Target
Here's Your Letter
All of This
Always

Rating out of 5
5

Blink 182 last album this one shows maturity of the band in their songs maybe this ones is considered their best job but not in the commercial way.